Billing Evidence: Spears v. Engorn

Kopec Law Firm

The Baltimore Medical Malpractice Lawyer Blog examines issues in medical malpractice cases from Maryland appellate court opinions. In this post the issue is whether a trial court abused its discretion by excluding in a medical malpractice case evidence of a doctor’s alleged improper billing practices when offered to attack the doctor’s credibility. The case is Spears v. Engorn, No. 1095, September Term, 2025, an unreported opinion filed November 4, 2026. The Appellate Court of Maryland issued this unreported opinion.

Factual Background on Billing Evidence in Medical Malpractice

In September 2020, the plaintiff sought medical care from the defendant doctor for bunions on both feet. First, the doctor advised conservative care, such as special shoes and bunion shields. However, those steps did not relieve the pain. Consequently, the doctor and the patient decided to proceed with a Lapidus surgery on the right foot. The doctor fused bones in the right foot using bone from the heel.

After the surgery, the patient had severe pain and swelling in her foot and ankle. Because of this pain, she did not put weight on the foot. The doctor gave her a walking boot and advised physical therapy. Yet, the patient did not wear the boot because it felt too heavy. Furthermore, she did not attend physical therapy despite repeated advice from the doctor. Seven weeks after the operation, she stopped seeing the defendant doctor.

The patient then sought treatment from a second orthopedic surgeon. This new surgeon saw that her foot was rigidly pointed downward. As a result, she could not wear a walking boot. Although she tried physical therapy several times, she stopped because of the pain. An MRI scan was hard to read due to the surgical metal in her foot. Still, the tendon at the front of the ankle looked intact on the scan.

Billing evidence in medical malpractice
Billing Evidence in Medical Malpractice

Subsequent Surgeries and Lawsuit

Because the foot remained stiff and the tendon did not work properly, the second surgeon operated. During that surgery, he found that the tendon was scarred down and out of place. Therefore, he sutured the tendon back onto the bone. Even so, the patient kept having pain, numbness, and spasms. Later, an MRI showed a split tear in that same tendon. As a result, the second surgeon performed two more surgeries.

The patient sued the first doctor and his medical practice in the Circuit Court for Montgomery County. She alleged medical malpractice and a lack of informed consent. During discovery, the plaintiff’s lawyer asked the defendant doctor about his billing codes for the 2020 surgery. In doing so, the lawyer used a 2024 medical billing manual. On advice of counsel, the doctor cited his Fifth Amendment right and refused to answer questions about billing fraud.

Next, the plaintiff’s medical expert witness testified at a deposition. He claimed the doctor “unbundled” the billing codes to charge three times for one surgery. However, the expert admitted this billing opinion was not in his written report. Instead, he stated it only went to the doctor’s honesty. Later, the plaintiff amended her complaint to add fraud and consumer protection claims.

Pre-Trial Rulings and Trial

Before trial, the defense moved to dismiss the new fraud counts and block any billing code testimony. The trial judge dismissed the consumer protection count and severed the fraud count from the trial. Then the judge ruled that billing code evidence could not come up at trial. Specifically, the judge noted that the plaintiff had to prove any prior bad act of dishonesty outside the jury’s presence.

The plaintiff filed two weeks before trial a motion to admit the billing evidence. She argued it showed the doctor had a motive to hide surgical risks to earn a higher bonus. After jury selection, the judge denied the motion. Ultimately, the judge refused to hold a “trial within a trial” on billing rules.

At trial, the defendant doctor testified that he never cut or detached the tendon. Moreover, three defense experts agreed that later scans proved the tendon was intact after the first surgery. Conversely, the plaintiff’s expert testified that the doctor detached the tendon while placing a metal plate. At the end of her case, the plaintiff dropped her informed consent claim. Finally, the jury found that the doctor was not negligent.

Parties’ Arguments on Billing Evidence in Medical Malpractice

On appeal, the plaintiff argued that the trial judge wrongly barred evidence of the doctor’s dishonesty. First, she claimed no court rule required her to give advance notice before using credibility evidence at trial. Second, she argued that the judge failed to weigh the value of the evidence against the risk of unfair prejudice. Third, she asserted that this error harmed her case because the trial turned on whether the jury believed the doctor.

In response, the defense argued that the plaintiff abandoned this issue when she dropped her informed consent claim at trial. Alternatively, the defense contended that the judge acted well within his discretion. Specifically, the defense noted that the plaintiff failed to meet the strict legal standard for proving a prior bad act. Finally, the defense pointed out that relying on a 2024 billing manual to judge 2020 billing made the claims irrelevant.

Court’s Ruling on Billing Evidence in Medical Malpractice

The Appellate Court of Maryland affirmed the trial judgment in favor of the defense. First, the appellate court rejected the claim that the issue was moot. Even though the plaintiff dropped her informed consent claim, the doctor’s general honesty remained central to the medical malpractice claim. Thus, the appellate court reviewed the evidentiary ruling for an abuse of discretion.

Next, the court analyzed Maryland Rule 5-608(b), which governs cross-examination about prior conduct showing untruthfulness. Under this rule, a lawyer may ask a witness about specific conduct that did not lead to a criminal conviction. However, if the other side objects, the questioner must first show a reasonable factual basis outside the jury’s presence. The rule forbids using outside evidence to prove that the conduct happened.

Failure to Establish a Factual Basis

Here, the appellate court held that the plaintiff failed to establish a reasonable factual basis for billing fraud. During the hearing, the plaintiff offered no valid proof that the doctor committed fraud. Her lawyer relied on a 2024 billing manual that did not exist during the 2020 surgery. Furthermore, Rule 5-608(b) barred the plaintiff from using the manual or her expert’s deposition as outside proof of misconduct.

Mere accusations of misconduct cannot be used to attack a witness’s honesty. Instead,the lawyer must show a firm basis that the bad act actually took place. Because the plaintiff failed this basic threshold test,the trial judge did not need to balance prejudice under Rule 5-403. Therefore, the trial court properly excluded the billing evidence.

Commentary by Baltimore Medical Malpractice Lawyer Mark Kopec on Billing Evidence in Medical Malpractice

This decision offers lessons for trial lawyers who want to challenge a defendant’s credibility using business or billing records. Under Maryland Rule 5-608(b), attacking a witness with prior dishonest acts is a narrow path with procedural traps. Attorneys must follow specific steps to preserve and present this type of evidence.

Do Not Rely on Extrinsic Evidence

First, is the ban on extrinsic evidence under Rule 5-608(b). When questioning a witness about a prior dishonest act, you must take the witness’s answer. Specifically, you cannot bring in outside documents, billing manuals, or another expert’s testimony to prove the witness lied. In this case, the plaintiff tried to use a coding manual and a retained expert to prove billing fraud. Because the rule bars outside proof, that strategy failed.

Instead, a lawyer must establish a reasonable factual basis for the bad act before asking the question in front of the jury. To do this, gather undisputed facts during discovery that match the exact time of the event. For example, if you challenge medical billing, you must use the exact coding rules in effect on the date of the surgery. Using a manual from four years later does not support your factual basis.

Address Fifth Amendment Invocations Early

Second, note how the defendant doctor invoked his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination during his deposition. In civil cases, a witness’s refusal to answer can sometimes allow an adverse inference. However, a lawyer cannot build a fraud accusation on a Fifth Amendment plea triggered by a flawed question. Because the deposition question relied on an inapplicable 2024 codebook, the refusal did not prove 2020 misconduct. When a witness pleads the Fifth in discovery, counsel must build a record on the underlying facts.

Use Timely Pre-Trial Motions and Proffers

Third, timing and procedure matter. While Rule 5-608(b) does not strictly force a party to file a pre-trial motion, waiting until close to trial is risky. Trial judges want to avoid sudden “trials within a trial” that confuse the jury and waste court time. Therefore, if you plan to attack a witness’s character for truthfulness, raise the issue early in accordance with the court’s scheduling order.

Finally, always make a clear, detailed proffer outside the jury’s presence. Do not rely on vague promises that you will “approach the bench” later if the issue comes up. When a judge asks for your factual basis, lay out the exact, admissible facts showing that the dishonest act occurred. If you skip this step, the judge may not have to weigh unfair prejudice under Rule 5-403, and your appeal may fail.

You can review other Blog posts on issues involving Evidence.

Mark Kopec is a top-rated Baltimore medical malpractice lawyer. Contact us at 800-604-0704 to speak directly with Attorney Kopec in a free consultation. The Kopec Law Firm is in Baltimore and helps clients throughout Maryland and Washington, D.C. Thank you for reading the Baltimore Medical Malpractice Lawyer Blog.

What Our Clients Say About Us

At the Kopec Law Firm, we are grateful that satisfied clients express their appreciation!

Dear Mark, I just wanted to express my gratitude for your dedication to my case. As you know, it has been a long and upsetting process for me, which would have been a great deal longer had it not been for the hours you put in helping me with this emotional roller coaster. Thank you again.

Shannon T. in Anne Arundel County

Dear Mark, thank you so much for your help and kindness. You provided the guidance and assistance we needed to obtain some understanding in loss of our child. We will never forget the professional and personal service provided. If anyone is in need of legal representation, I will certainly send them your way. God bless.

Kim C. in Cecil County

I wanted to say thank you for spending time with me regarding my questions about legal issues. Mere words cannot really express my gratitude. You seem to truly care about people.

Client in Baltimore City

Dear Mr. Mark, I’m truly grateful to have had you work on my son’s case. You were up front at all times and were on key every step of the way. I will always recommend your firm. Thank you so much for helping my son. P.S. Every time my son sees you on TV, he says “Mom, that’s my lawyer, Mr. Mark.” 🙂 Thank you again. You did an excellent job on the...

K.N. in Baltimore City

Dear Mark, we want to thank you for all the hard work and time your firm put in our case. You took the time to listen to us and research our case. You were honest and up front regarding the case. You responded to questions and concerns quickly. We would highly recommend your firm and services to anyone who is in need of legal representation. We...

Rebecca T. in Prince George’s County

Super Awesome team and staff! Worked with them for a case they handled for my grandchild about 10yrs ago! Would definitely use them again! I recommend them to everyone I know. Could never thank them enough! Very thorough and knowledgeable! Always kept us in the loop throughout the entire process!!!!

Letha C. in Prince George’s County

Mark explained everything in detail and brought clarity to all of my concerns.

Doris in Edgwater

I am very happy and thankful for your help. You responded very quickly. I am very happy to recommend you.

Linda in Chevy Chase

Mark is a knowledgeable and empathetic lawyer who speaks directly and concisely to evaluate your problem. He doesn't use attorney jargon that confuses people, rather he talks clearly. Although he couldn't help me with my situation, the consultation I had was productive because he answered my questions and gave me some clarity.

Shahnaz in Ellicott City
  1. 1 Free Consultation
  2. 2 Talk to a Lawyer
  3. 3 No Fee Unless You Win
Fill out the contact form or call us at 800-604-0704 to schedule your consultation.

Send Us a Message